
Not with a bread machine like I used to back when I made fresh, warm loaves more frequently. No, I didn’t even remember how to use the bread machine anymore, so I decided to just mix, knead, and bake the old-fashioned way. What could go wrong, right?
I found a recipe on someone's blog that looked promising—golden crust, pillowy inside, and totally gluten-free. Perfect! Or so I thought.
From the start, things were… off. The dough was incredibly dry and crumbly, refusing to come together into anything remotely resembling the soft, stretchy ball I imagined.
I started to become discouraged (and annoyed), then improvised—adding additional oil, then vegan Greek yogurt, hoping to bring it back to life.
Looking back, my first mistake was trusting the recipe blindly and dumping in all 5 cups of flour right away. Rookie move. I should’ve known better and should have added the flour slowly to see how much it actually needed.
To make things worse, this wasn’t a cheap experiment. A 2-pound bag of gluten-free bread flour cost me $9.99.
Still, I wasn’t ready to give up. I coaxed it into a vaguely dough-like state, kneaded it, and let it rise. Or rather, I hoped it would rise. Despite proofing the yeast, the dough stayed stubbornly low and did not rise. But I braided it the best I could anyway, brushed it with some maple syrup, popped it in the oven, and crossed my fingers.
The result? Well… imagine a soft pretzel pretending to be a loaf of bread. I ended up with 5 small creations/soft pretzels. They were sweet because I glazed them with maple syrup.
What I Learned About Gluten-Free Bread Baking
Don’t trust a recipe blindly—especially with gluten-free dough.
Add flour gradually, adjusting for texture and moisture.
Even a “failed” loaf can be edible and tasty.
In the end, my braided gluten-free bread wasn’t bakery-perfect, but it was fun, flavorful, and we got some good laughs. Two of my grandkids were visiting for dinner (and that's why I made homemade bread) and they liked it, ate it, and took some home. One of the two visiting is gluten-free.
But here’s the twist: it actually tasted good. In fact, I may have tasted way too much of it straight out of the oven when it was warm, sweet, and lightly crunchy. It wasn’t what I planned, but it was still kind of good in its own quirky way.
Moral of the story? I will be searching for a better gluten-free bread recipe before my next attempt.
In the meantime, I'll call this A gluten-free baking experiment full of dry dough, braided pretzels, and happy grandkids. but don’t ask for the recipe. Trust me, you would not want it.
On another note- It's beginning to look like fall and the night's and early mornings are cooler (around 48 degrees to 50). The days are still warm and into the low 80's.
Halloween Decorations are out already |
Sugar pumpkins being sold to make pumpkin pie |
Nice outline of trials in the kitchen! I have had a few of those myself here lately, at the very least, the hens are happy, and I learned something in the process.
ReplyDeletetoo bad I can't give mine to your hens
DeleteI'm sorry, but I did laugh at your pretzel bread. Who cares so long as it's tasty?
ReplyDeleteI laughed too !!
DeleteWell, at least you ended up with something edible -- even tasty! It so could have gone the other way. (And the maple glaze is a great idea!). Your fall photos are beautiful too! What a great season!
ReplyDeleteYes, we did eat it and kind of enjoy it.
DeleteI'm sorry it didn't turn out the way you wanted it to but at least it was tasty. That's always the most important thing. Love the fall pictures. We're having cooler nights with hot days but a cool down in predicted for next week.
ReplyDeleteIt's my second time trying GF bread and ending up with soft pretzels. I'll have to watch some YouTube.
DeleteThere is something almost primeval about baking bread. Every cultures has its own version but they all have legend, myth and other worldly connection to life itself. Congratulations on getting back to baking bread.
ReplyDeleteWell I might keep trying but I have to improve.
DeleteDealing with gluten-free flour is such a tricky business, and your learning curve about adding the flour slowly and not trusting a recipe blindly is excellent advice, especially since that flour is so expensive. It is wonderful that you turned a potential misadventure into something fun and tasty, and it is so lovely that the changing weather is making it feel like fall. What a wonderful way to spend a Saturday; I hope you are having a deeply meaningful and peaceful weekend
ReplyDeleteYes - I thought because I bought GF bread flour which has some additives to help it appear more glutinous, it would be easier- but it's not.
DeleteBaking gluten free bread can be quite tricky...at least your effort didn't go to waste.
ReplyDeletetrue on both accounts Angie.
DeleteAt least it tasted good, that's the important part. I used to bake bread all the time but I never tried anything gluten free. Fall is looking really nice in your neck of the woods!
ReplyDeleteYes, it is starting to look and feel like fall but our weather is still a little too hot during the day.
DeleteAs long as you made something tasty and edible, this is what counts, dear Judee. :)
ReplyDeleteTrue- we did end up with something edible
DeleteMy wife tried gluten free baking years ago and it was difficult. We don't do that any longer.
ReplyDeleteI understand why.
DeleteYour adventure reminded me of my first attempt at bread after I got out of college. Your end result looks way tastier than mine did! I don't try making bread anymore. Your dishes always looks so yummy.
ReplyDeleteI used to bake bread before being gluten-free and I had much better results. I've made GF cakes and cookies with luck.
DeleteI've only made gluten free bread for my dad once and in the bread maker. I've made 100% rye loaves which are dense and heavy but very tasty. Good luck with your experiment.
ReplyDeleteTandy (Lavender and Lime) https://tandysinclair.com
Thanks Tandy. Glad you rye bread came out well.
DeleteI'd eat it! Least you had something to eat at the end of it. Great Hallowe'en photos :-D
ReplyDeleteYes we did eat it and it was kind of good bc I put the maple syrup glaze and it kept it softer too.
DeleteThank you for this post! We all do this sort of thing, and it's always good to be reminded that we're not alone. I wish I knew about gluten-free baking so that I could help you!
ReplyDeleteI might be giving up..
DeleteI'm so sorry that recipe let you down but at least you ended up with something yummy and edible in the end. Your weather is sounding a lot like ours. It definitely look like fall here too but it's so dry that many of the leaves are dropping without much color change happening.
ReplyDeleteYes, edible is the word- not great - but edible
DeleteOh Judee, I know what you mean about when a recipe sounds good in print and then doesn't come out right. I agree, it can be expensive! I made a strawberry cake recipe this past spring and it was a complete disaster. But I'm glad that your bread tasted great in the end....that's a good thing. 58 degrees here in SC in the morning and I'm just loving it.
ReplyDeleteCheers!
I was disappointed especially since bread making is time consuming
DeleteShame on the writer of that bake for not having tested it with someone else first. I see this a lot with writers of bakes. They don't do the extra work. I even hear some of them talk about how they don't test their formulas/recipes. Why? Why not have things tested?
ReplyDeleteWhen I get back to sharing videos and how-to, I have a GF, VG waffle formula. Whilst not bread, really good warmed with peanut butter on top.
LOOOOVE all the Halloween goodies on your page 🎃🧡👻🍂🤍🕷️💜🕸️
I should have read the comments to see if anyone else tried it. Now I can't even remember which blog I got the recipe from
DeleteSorry that the recipe did not turn out as you'd hoped but at least you had success in the end.
ReplyDeleteYour photographs are beautiful, I do like Autumn.
All the best Jan
Yes, true.
DeleteOh no. We have to chalk it up to experience when this happens.
ReplyDeleteExactly and move on..
DeleteTaste is what matters.
ReplyDeletersrue.blogspot.com
Well it was ok but not as expected and more like a soft pretzel
DeleteYou try and you learn... the next one will be better.
ReplyDeleteLovely photos.
thank you.
DeleteAt least you were able to work some magic into the dough and still get something tasty in the end, so I'd say that's a win! Hope you find a better recipe next time!
ReplyDeleteYes, true- we did at least eat it- sad as it was.
DeleteAbsolutely a valiant attempt! Gluten-free bread really is tough, often in more ways than one.
ReplyDeleteYes, I need to watch a few YouTube demos...
DeleteGluten-free flour can be so tricky to work with. Even regular flour bread baking can be discouraging. I feel your pain! If once you don't succeed, try again . Take Care
ReplyDelete